Saturday, November 8, 2008

thought of the day.136

Empathy, not scripture, is the basis of morality.

7 comments:

homesicksooner said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
homesicksooner said...

You are right that scripture is not the basis for morality. Scripture is God revealing himself to us. God's character and nature are the basis for morality.

john evans said...

Is it the part where God punishes the innocent people living in a palace with great suffering (story of Abram’s betrayal of Sarai), his drowning of every child in the world, his burning other children alive with fire from heaven, his commands of murder and genocide, regulation of slavery, demands to be satisfied by primitive blood sacrifices, oppression of women and children, his jealous nature and persecution of other religions, discrimination against the physically challenged, his angry punishing nature, etc that is the basis for morality or something else?

homesicksooner said...

The philosophical problem of evil is a tough one for EVERY system of belief including atheism. Christians have an answer to the question though.

However, I'm more interested to how you respond to it.

How does naturalism or atheism account for evil (please, lets not play word games), suffering, bad things happening to good people, or whatever you want to call it?

john evans said...

Evil is a non-issue. Nothing at all mysterious about evil. It is simply a word that describes an especially abhorent act.

And our ideas about what is evil are always evolving.

homesicksooner said...

Our ideas about what is evil are always evolving?

So in the future we might think something like 9/11 or the Holocaust was a good thing.

We might even get to a point some day where we think it's virtuous to prostitute young children.

Perhaps if evolution goes well, we might one day embrace rape and murder.

Please don't offer a red herring here. Address the issues.

john evans said...

I am not sure what I am responding to here. Are you suggesting our ideas of good and evil are not constantly evolving?

It was once considered good to own slaves, preachers assured their flocks that slavery ”was of God“. But our sense of good and evil evolved and we now consider it evil.

There is a clear if uneven trend toward greater sensitivity to “the other”. Whether that other be women, minorities, children, animals, the earth itself, etc.

I am always excited when my own sense of good and evil changes, evolves. Hopefully I am becoming more sensitive to more things all the time. For example, I now consider it evil to raise animals in factory farms and to kill animals needlessly. I believe someday we will no longer do such things. I believe it is evil to poison a child’s mind with the fear of hell. It is evil to torture prisoners the way our government does. Etc, etc.