Thursday, June 4, 2009

thought of the day.313

Problems don’t exist outside our mind.

6 comments:

myrtle church said...

Hello John,

"Problems don’t exist outside our mind."!!!??

Try telling that to someone who has just broken a leg or cannot get clean water & has amoebic dysentery.

:)

john evans said...

Hi myrtle. Always a pleasure to hear from you.

What I’m suggesting is that the broken leg and dirty water are not problems in and of themselves. They are just conditions of reality.

It takes our senses to perceive reality and our mind to assess it and only then does a “problem” (I can’t walk or I need fresh water) “materialize”.

And depending on the state of our mind we will see reality differently. In the minds of the people chasing John Wilkes Boothe his broken leg was not a “problem” but a “God send”.

Unknown said...

But what if you're someone like me with a broken ankle? I didn't kill anybody yet I still can't walk until September...

How isn't that a problem?

I would think you of all people, who is concerned about ending all suffering, would not have given "there are no problems" any credibility whatsoever.

john evans said...

Kelsie, So sorry to hear about your ankle! Hope you heal quickly. How did you break it?

I understand this idea is a little bit counterintuitive. I am not saying there are no problems or that there is no suffering. Certainly, the world is full of both. But “problems” are human concepts. A broken ankle may be reality but it only becomes a problem when you decide it is.

For instance, you could have been scheduled to be sent to the front lines of the war in Iraq and had second thoughts about joining the army and did not want to go as everyone who went was killed. A broken ankle that excused you from going and saved your life is not a problem then.

The point of the thought is that “problems” do not exist apart from humans (or other creatures that can conceive of them.) They don’t exist like a tree exists but this certainly does not mean they are not real. It shows that the individual SUBJECTIVE mind that is assessing the situation determines whether or not the situation is a problem or not. And our frame of mind can make the problem seem like a golden opportunity our an impossible obstacle or something in between.

homesicksooner said...

John, if the ideas you have about "problems" are coming from your mind, how can you trust them?

The ideas you are espousing ultimately self-refute because what you are saying is coming from your mind.

john evans said...

Sooner, You can prove my point wrong by simply providing an example of a “problem” that exists outside the mind. I don’t think you can, but would love to be proved wrong. Good luck.